Montauk, NY 11954 - Home Prices, Rental Trends, Listings & Demographics | Prop:Metrics

Montauk, NY—11954

Real Estate Data & Market Trends

Key Metrics at a Glance

Median Home Value

$1,953,000

2.9% YoY Growth

Household Income

$129,000

35.8% YoY Growth

Days on Market

143

26.0% Longer YoY

Home Price Forecast

2.0%

Median Rent

$9,870

26.3% YoY Growth

1-Bed Rent

$10,000

61.0% YoY Growth

2-Bed Rent

$8,000

8.3% YoY Growth

3-Bed Rent

$9,870

13.2% YoY Growth

Home Price Trends — Montauk, NY

As of Dec '25, the median home price in Montauk, NY is $1,953,000, with a year-over-year change of 2.9%. This indicates that home prices in Montauk, NY are increasing. According to Zillow, the 1-year price projection is 2.0%, suggesting an increase housing market in the next year.

Cost per Home Type

Home Type	Median Home Value	YoY % Change
All Homes	$1,953,000	2.9%
Single Family	$2,058,000	0.2%
Condos	N/A	N/A

Cost per Home Size

Home Size	Median Home Value	YoY % Change
1 Bed

Rental Trends — Montauk, NY

As of July '25, Rentcast reports the average rent in Montauk, NY is $8,740, with a year-over-year rent change of 26.3%. Per bedroom, the median rent as of July '25 in Montauk, NY is 1-bedrooms: $10,000, 2-bedrooms: $7,570, 3-bedrooms: $9,190. The most common rental property sizes in Montauk, NY are 2-bedroom and 3-bedroom, accounting for 45.7% and 19.5% of the rental stock.

Type	Median Rent	Average Rent
Average Rent	$9,870	$8,740
Studio Rent	N/A	N/A
1 Bed Rent	$10,000	$10,000
2 Bed Rent	$8,000	$7,570
3 Bed Rent	$9,870	$9,190
4 Bed Rent	N/A	N/A

Loading chart...

% of Rental Stock

Studio

5.1%

1 Bedroom

16.9%

2 Bedrooms

45.7%

3 Bedrooms

19.5%

5+ Bedrooms

12.8%

Property Listings — Montauk, NY

As of Dec '25, Realtor.com reports that the median days on market for a home in Montauk, NY is 135. This is a decrease of -1.0% from last year, suggesting that homes are sitting on the market about the same amount of time than last year. The percentage of listed homes with a reduced price is 0.0%, representing a small inventory and little supply pressure on home prices.

Metric	Zip Code Average	Year over Year % Change
Median Listing Price	$2,620,000	-3.0%
Listing Count	98	2.0%
Listings as % of Homes	1.6%	2.0%
Days on Market	143	26.0%

Loading chart...

Demographics — Montauk, NY

As of the latest ACS Survey released in 2023, Montauk, NY has a population of 4,070, which has increased by 11.4% over the past 5 years. Montauk, NY is a moderately popular place for families, as children make up 18.6% of the population. The area has a highly educated workforce, with 48.9% of adult residents holding a bachelor’s degree or higher. There are some residents working remotely, with 20.0% reporting working from home.

Metric	Latest Census	YoY % Change
Population	4,070	11.4%
% Under 18	18.6%	40.9%
% Seniors	23.5%	-19.2%
% WFH	20.0%	124.7%
% w/ College Degree	48.9%	13.7%

Loading chart...

As of the latest ACS Survey released in 2023, Montauk, NY is a predominantly white area, with 89.1% of the population identifying as white. The white population has grown by 7.5% in the last 5 years. The second most common race or ethnicity in Montauk, NY is hispanic, making up 6.4% of the population. Foreign-born residents account for 10.0% of the population in Montauk, NY, and this percentage has decreased by 13.0% as of the ACS Survey 5 years prior, suggesting fewer immigrants are calling the area home.

Race and Ethnicity

Metric	Latest Census	5-Year % Change
% White	89.1%	7.5%
% Black	1.4%	100.0%
% Hispanic	6.4%	-54.9%
% Asian	0.0%	-100.0%
% Foreign Born	10.0%	-13.0%

Loading chart...

Mortgage and Risk — Montauk, NY

According to HUD data as of 2023, there were 72 mortgage originations in Montauk, NY, of which 99.0% of loans were conventional mortgages. The average loan-to-value was 45.0%, with 1.0% above 90% LTV (normal). This implies small mortgage risk in Montauk, NY. Investor activity is low, as 3.0% of loans were by investors. 18.0% of loans were cash-out refinances, suggesting many homeowners are tapping equity.

Mortgages

Metric	Zip Code Average
Total Loan Originations	72
% Conventional Loans	99.0%
% Government Loans	1.0%
% Investor Loans	3.0%
% Second Loans	51.0%
% Cash Out Refinance	18.0%

Loading chart...

Rentals and Section 8 — Montauk, NY

Montauk, NY lacks sufficient Section 8 program data for analysis.

Section 8 Market Size

Total Units under HUD	37
Total Units Section 8	37
% Rentals under Section 8	12.1%
% Occupied Section 8	N/A

Section 8 Opportunity

Home Size	HUD Premium	Market Rent	Max HUD Rent
1 Bedroom	-$7,280	$10,000	$2,720
2 Bedroom	-$4,860	$8,000	$3,140
3 Bedroom	-$5,800	$9,870	$4,070
4 Bedroom	N/A	N/A	$4,360

Montauk, NY—11954

Key Metrics at a Glance

Home Price Trends — Montauk, NY

Cost per Home Type

Cost per Home Size

% of Housing Stock

Rental Trends — Montauk, NY

% of Rental Stock

Property Listings — Montauk, NY

Demographics — Montauk, NY

Race and Ethnicity

Mortgage and Risk — Montauk, NY

Mortgages

Rentals and Section 8 — Montauk, NY

Section 8 Market Size

Section 8 Opportunity

Affordability — Montauk, NY

Home Price to Income Ratio

Montauk, NY — ZIP Code Boundary Map

Nearby ZIP Codes

Devon

East Hampton, NY

Wainscott, NY

Groton, CT

Groton, CT

Frequently Asked Questions

Metric	Zip Code Average
Home Price to Income Ratio	14
Median Home Price	$1,953,000
Median Household Income	$129,000

Montauk, NY—11954

Key Metrics at a Glance

Home Price Trends — Montauk, NY

Cost per Home Type

Cost per Home Size

% of Housing Stock

Rental Trends — Montauk, NY

% of Rental Stock

Property Listings — Montauk, NY

Demographics — Montauk, NY

Race and Ethnicity

Mortgage and Risk — Montauk, NY

Mortgages

Rentals and Section 8 — Montauk, NY

Section 8 Market Size

Section 8 Opportunity

Affordability — Montauk, NY

Home Price to Income Ratio

Montauk, NY — ZIP Code Boundary Map

Nearby ZIP Codes

Devon

East Hampton, NY

Wainscott, NY

Groton, CT

Groton, CT

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the average home price in Montauk, NY 11954?

How have home prices in Montauk, NY 11954 changed over the past year?

What is the home price projection for Montauk, NY 11954?

What are the demographics of Montauk, NY 11954?

How long does it take homes to sell in Montauk, NY 11954?

What is the average rent price in Montauk, NY 11954?